5 Worst Heat Pump Brands To Avoid And 7 Most Reliable Brands (Buying Guide)
As winter approaches, it’s clear that heat pumps are more crucial than ever. These versatile systems provide both heating and air conditioning functions by transferring heat from a home’s interior to the outside for cooler air circulation. Often paired with gas furnaces, heat pumps can efficiently manage heat loads. When selecting a heat pump, understanding the best and worst brands is vital to ensure you choose one that meets your needs and preferences.
With this in mind, it’s essential to explore reliable heat pump brands like Tempstar, Goodman, Daikin, Maytag, York, Carrier and Bryant, as well as Trane. On the other hand, identifying bad heat pumps requires attention to signs such as high energy bills, poor airflow, unusual noises or smells, and decreased heating performance.
When buying a heat pump, it’s crucial to avoid common mistakes like purchasing a bargain unit without proper installation, neglecting reviews, overlooking SEER ratings, and failing to consider maintenance contracts and warranties. By considering these factors, you’ll be better equipped to make an informed decision when selecting a heat pump.
5 Worst Heat Pump Brands
When it comes to heat pumps, quality can vary significantly between brands. To make an informed decision, reading reviews is crucial. Rather than focusing solely on the best heat pump brands, this section aims to highlight some of the worst offenders. Our analysis draws from customer feedback gathered from prominent online retailers and review platforms, as well as ratings from reputable consumer organizations.
Lennox International
Lennox, a well-known brand in the industry, may seem out of place on this list due to its extensive market presence. However, despite its widespread reach, customer satisfaction is marred by concerns over product durability. Numerous reviews highlight that Lennox heat pumps are more prone to breaking than those from other brands.
Furthermore, customers often cite the company’s tendency to manufacture and sell smaller components that are difficult for consumers to access as a major contributor to their higher repair and maintenance costs. Interestingly, Lennox is also the parent company of other brands like Air Ease, Armstrong Air, and Ducane, which boast better efficiency ratings than Lennox itself.
Ameristar
While Lennox is renowned as one of the premier American brands for heat pumps, its reputation doesn’t necessarily translate to exceptional efficiency. In fact, many consumers have reported concerns about its overall efficiency rather than reliability issues. One area where Lennox excels is in providing solid fundamental heating, ventilation, and air conditioning capabilities. However, a SEER rating of 13-14 falls short of industry standards, according to Consumer Reports’ ratings.
This lower rating can lead to higher energy costs on consumers’ bills, which was a recurring theme in reviews and feedback about this brand.
Ruud
Ruud, a well-established brand in the HVAC industry, has built a reputation over the years for its popular product lines. However, their track record with heat pumps has been marred by reliability issues, earning them a dubious distinction as one of the least trustworthy brands in the market. A recent report highlights the significant problems faced by Ruud’s heat pump products, which have had a profound impact on the brand’s standing in the industry.
In response, the company has made a concerted effort to overhaul its focus on quality and reliability, with the goal of regaining consumer trust. While it may take some time for Ruud to regain its former momentum, experts predict that it will take at least a couple of years before they can reclaim their spot in the market.
Rheem
While Ruud is its parent brand, it’s no surprise that Carrier shares similar concerns regarding heating and furnaces. Despite being a well-known brand, Carrier has faced criticism for performance and reliability issues, tarnishing its reputation. Online reviews have been particularly scathing, with many stating that the company’s products don’t quite live up to expectations.
Like Ruud, Carrier is currently focusing on improving the efficiency and reliability of its heating pumps, seemingly in response to customer complaints. While it’s too early to say whether these efforts will pay off, the fact that they’re taking steps to address the issue suggests a willingness to learn from past mistakes.
Nordyne
While this brand prioritizes affordability, noise level, and reliability, its products may not be the most solidly built or durable options available at that price point. As a result, it’s not necessarily a top recommendation. In fact, many HVAC installation crews have had issues with Nordyne equipment not lasting as long as expected.
A quick review of online reviews reveals a common complaint about the brand’s products breaking down prematurely, which is something to consider before choosing this brand.
7 Most Reliable Heat Pump Brands
While some manufacturers may be inconsistent in their product offerings, there are indeed well-established brands that consistently deliver on reliability and efficiency. For those seeking a reliable heat pump option, it’s worth starting your search with these reputable brands that have a track record of producing high-quality products.
Tempstar Heat Pumps
Tempstar, a renowned heat pump brand, rivals Carrier and Bryant models in terms of quality and affordability. As a subsidiary of International Comfort Products (ICP), Tempstar benefits from rigorous manufacturing standards, ensuring its products stand the test of time. The Copeland compressor, another respected name in the industry, plays a significant role in boosting efficiency.
Furthermore, the brand’s focus on ease of repair is impressive, with readily available and cost-effective spare parts. Additionally, Tempstar’s comprehensive 5-10 year warranty is a major selling point, offering total product replacement rather than just repairs. According to customer reviews, Tempstar has earned its reputation as a top-tier heat pump brand.
Goodman Heat Pumps
Since its acquisition by HVAC, Goodman Heat Pumps has undergone significant improvements, solidifying its reputation as a high-quality brand in the industry. The brand’s popularity stems from its affordability, making it an attractive option for those seeking budget-friendly heat pump solutions. Like Tempstar, Goodman Heat Pumps leverages Copeland compressors and the highly-regarded UltraTech scroll compressor to deliver reliable performance.
Warranty coverage varies depending on the product model, with some models boasting lifetime protection and others offering a 10-year guarantee. Overall, based on customer reviews, Goodman Heat Pumps is the top choice for affordable heat pumps that deliver exceptional results.
Daikin Heat Pumps
The Goodman Global Group Inc.’s underling is a heat pump that stands out due to its affiliation with a reputable brand, although it comes at a higher price point compared to Goodman’s own products. Notably, this model has seen an improvement in customer ratings, jumping from the top 15 to top 21. A key feature that sets it apart is its use of an inverter-driven compressor courtesy of Copeland.
Perhaps most attractive, however, is the unit’s impressive 12-year warranty, which not only covers premature repairs but also provides peace of mind with regard to product replacement within the specified warranty period.
Maytag Heat Pumps
While many people may not be aware that Maytag produces heat pumps and other HVAC products, the company deserves recognition for its commendable performance in the industry. As a subsidiary of Nortek Global, formerly known as Nordyne, Maytag benefits from its parent company’s reputation for quality and reliability. The brand’s durable compressor is particularly noteworthy, along with the easy availability of replacement parts should any issues arise.
Additionally, Maytag’s 12-year warranty offers customers peace of mind when choosing this brand, much like Daikin’s similar offering.
York Heat Pumps
One notable brand that offers high-quality heat pumps is York Heat Pumps, a subsidiary of Johnson Controls alongside its sister brands Luxaire, Coleman, and Champion. This partnership allows for the creation of premium heat pumps with a focus on upgrading their lineup and enhancing efficiency in recent years.
What sets York apart from other brands is its commitment to manufacturing its own coils and providing an industry-leading lifetime compressor warranty, as well as a ten-year general parts warranty. These comprehensive guarantees make York a highly desirable option for those seeking reliable heat pump solutions.
Carrier and Bryant Heat Pump
The industry leader in question boasts an impressive market presence, with its products widely available and sought after by many. While they deliver on quality, their warranty periods are relatively shorter compared to others. This may seem counterintuitive given the high-end nature of their offerings, but it’s largely due to their commitment to crafting long-lasting products that require minimal maintenance.
The brand stands out for utilizing Copeland compressors, which come with a 10-year guarantee on both compressor and other parts. Although this warranty period is relatively shorter than some competitors, the brand’s exceptional durability, longevity, and impressive rating of 21.5 make it an attractive option for those seeking a reliable purchase.
Trane heat pumps
Trane stands out as a top choice when it comes to high-efficiency, quiet operation, and value. Consumers rave about this brand due to its ability to help homeowners save money on their electricity bills through its efficient performance. Additionally, Trane is known for being the quietest brand in the market. When it comes to selecting the right model for your home, you have a range of options from Trane, and a local comfort specialist can help you find the best fit.
Furthermore, Trane’s affordability is another major plus, making it the top choice among consumer reviews.
How to identify a bad heat pump
High Energy Bills
When faced with an unexpected surge in electric bills, it’s natural to scrutinize appliances that may require repair. When assessing your heat pumps, consider whether replacing worn-out components like filters would be a viable solution or if the entire unit needs attention. To accurately diagnose any issues, consulting a trusted HVAC professional for expert guidance is highly recommended.
Poor Airflow
The primary culprit behind poor airflow is often the ductwork itself. However, even when the ducts are clean, clear of debris, and leak-free, other factors can still contribute to the issue. Heat pumps, in particular, may be at fault if they’re not functioning properly. Similarly, dirty air filters, dusty coils, an inactive motor, or other underlying issues can all hinder airflow.
While regular maintenance is crucial for identifying and resolving these problems, it’s often wise to seek the expertise of HVAC professionals to pinpoint the exact cause and provide a effective solution.
Weird Noises
When a heat pump is running smoothly, it’s not uncommon to hear a gentle humming or whirring sound. However, if you notice any unusual noises, it’s essential to take immediate action and consult with your HVAC professional. A sudden change in the sounds emitted by your heat pump can be indicative of an underlying issue that requires prompt attention. For instance, a loose belt or malfunctioning fan might be the root cause of the problem.
Strange Smells
If you’ve noticed your heat pumps emitting unusual odors, it’s time to take action. A musty or rotting smell can indicate the presence of mold or even the remains of animals that may have taken up residence in the system. Similarly, a burning smell could be a sign of an electrical issue, posing a potential danger. If you detect any strange smells emanating from your heat pumps, it’s crucial to investigate further and consider consulting with an HVAC professional for guidance.
If it no longer heats your home
When a heat pump fails to deliver its primary function of heating a home, it’s a clear sign that it’s nearing the end of its lifespan. If you’re no longer feeling the warmth, it’s essential to take swift action and schedule an inspection with your trusted HVAC professional. They’ll be able to diagnose the issue, whether it’s due to worn-out components or something more complex. In some cases, the problem may require a replacement, while in others, a repair might be sufficient.
Whatever the outcome, it’s crucial to address the issue promptly to ensure a comfortable and energy-efficient living space.
Mistakes to avoid when buying a heat pump
Buying the Bargain Unit
When investing in a new appliance for your home, prioritize purchasing a high-quality brand-new product over a used or older model. While the initial cost savings may be appealing, opting for a newer device from a reputable manufacturer will ultimately provide better long-term performance and value. It’s essential to weigh the upfront expense against the potential benefits of a longer-lasting, more reliable appliance that meets your expectations.
Not hiring a professional when installing the unit
While cost-cutting measures may be tempting, DIY installations can be ill-advised when it comes to certain appliances. When purchasing a new unit, it’s often wiser to seek out one that is well-suited for the task at hand or opt for professional installation services from the seller. Paying a premium upfront can prove more cost-effective in the long run than facing potential complications and additional expenses down the line.
Not checking reviews
In today’s digitally-driven world, it’s commonplace for individuals to research products thoroughly before making a purchase. One crucial aspect of this process is reviewing feedback from those who have previously acquired the product. By doing so, consumers can gain valuable insights into what makes a particular product stand out and what might be lacking. This approach allows wise buyers to make informed decisions, knowing exactly what they’re getting themselves into.
Not minding the SEER rating
When considering the purchase of a heat pump, it’s crucial to examine the SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) rating. This metric indicates the efficiency level of the brand, allowing you to make an informed decision about which heat pump to invest in. A higher SEER rating generally translates to lower energy consumption and reduced electricity bills over time. By prioritizing this factor, you can ensure a more cost-effective and sustainable heating solution for your home.
Purchasing a brand new (but the cheapest ones)
Before investing in a heat pump, it’s crucial to assess your home’s unique characteristics and requirements. This includes considering factors such as your home’s layout, insulation, and overall energy efficiency. By taking the time to inspect your home’s internal conditions, you’ll be better equipped to identify what type of heat pump will best suit your needs.
This proactive approach can save you time and effort when shopping for a heat pump, allowing you to focus on finding the most suitable option for your specific situation. Furthermore, it’s essential not to get too caught up in the allure of brand-new, discounted heat pumps if they don’t align with your home’s specific demands. Instead, prioritize finding a solution that will provide optimal performance and energy efficiency for years to come.
Not checking the Price beforehand
When considering the purchase of a heat pump, it’s crucial to have a realistic understanding of the prices involved. This can be achieved by conducting online research or seeking advice from individuals who have already acquired similar appliances. It’s essential to ask questions and gather information about different products and their corresponding price points before making a decision.
Moreover, it’s always wise to verify the price of your chosen heat pump before placing an order to avoid any potential surprises.
Purchasing heat pump sizes that are not suited In your area
When selecting a heat pump, it’s essential to consider the ideal size for your specific application. A key takeaway is that one-size-fits-all approaches don’t apply here. Rather, you’ll want to seek guidance from experts or individuals who have successfully navigated this process in the past. Proper sizing is crucial, as it directly impacts the overall performance and efficiency of your heat pump.
By taking the time to carefully consider your needs and receive informed advice, you can ensure a seamless installation and optimal operating experience.
Not paying attention to the brand
When investing in a heat pump, it’s crucial to prioritize quality over convenience. Avoid settling for subpar brands that may be readily available but lack the necessary expertise and support. Instead, take the time to research reputable manufacturers that offer comprehensive services. While premium options may seem costly upfront, they can ultimately save you money and hassle by providing reliable performance and dedicated customer assistance.
Missing rebate opportunities
When investing in a brand-new heat pump, it’s crucial to inquire about available rebates from the manufacturer. Many companies offer these incentives to drive sales and attract customers. It’s essential to take advantage of this marketing strategy by asking about potential rebates for cash or credit purchases. The more efficient and costly the product, the higher the rebate typically is. Be sure to negotiate with the seller to get the best deal possible.
Not considering maintenance contracts and warranty
When investing in a high-end heat pump, it’s crucial to consider the warranty and maintenance provisions upfront. A lengthy warranty period and complimentary maintenance can significantly reduce overall costs and provide peace of mind. Don’t overlook these essential factors, as they can make all the difference in your purchasing decision. Similarly, when acquiring any new appliance or machinery, prioritize warranties and maintenance to ensure a hassle-free ownership experience.
Frequently Asked Questions About Heat Pump Brands
Which heat pump is best for Consumer Reports?
Trane is renowned for its exceptional dependability and customer satisfaction, making it a top choice among many. Its reliability and high efficiency are unparalleled, ensuring a comfortable living space for years to come. Specifically designed for cool to moderately warm climates, Trane heat pumps excel in providing consistent warmth during the colder months.
The use of Climatuff compressors and Spine Fin outdoor coils is particularly noteworthy, as these components contribute to the brand’s exceptional performance. While the initial installation cost may be higher due to Trane’s advanced design and features, the long-term benefits to one’s comfort and energy efficiency make it a worthwhile investment.
How many years does a heat pump last?
While some heat pumps can reliably last 20 years with proper maintenance, others may have a shorter lifespan of around 15 years. To ensure your heat pump reaches its full potential and lasts as long as possible, it’s essential to stay vigilant for any unusual noises or signs that maintenance is needed. When it comes to repairs, trust only certified professionals who specialize in heat pumps, rather than relying on general handymen.
Regular cleaning is also crucial, as is addressing repairable parts immediately to prevent further damage and prolong the overall lifespan of your heat pump.
Is Goodman a good heat pump brand?
Goodman’s reputation precedes it as a purveyor of budget-friendly heat pumps. As an subsidiary of HVAC, Goodman has consistently delivered value-packed products that balance affordability with quality. Over the years, the brand has continued to innovate and refine its offerings, solidifying its position as a reliable choice for those seeking effective yet economical solutions.
What is the best brand of ductless heat pump?
When it comes to choosing the best ductless heat pump brand, Mitsubishi stands out from the rest. While it may be more expensive than other options on the market, its exceptional warranties, impressive features, cost-effective operation, extensive selection, convenient design, and unparalleled efficiency make it a top contender. Furthermore, Mitsubishi’s commitment to quality, durability, and customer convenience sets it apart as the premier ductless heat pump brand.
Its innovative technologies not only boost system efficiency but also eliminate hot and cold spots, provide cleaner air for your home, and allow for remote control. This comprehensive package makes Mitsubishi the clear winner in the world of ductless heat pumps.
What heat pumps are made in the USA?
When it comes to heat pump manufacturers, there are several prominent US-based brands worth considering. Trane, Carrier, and Bryant are all household names with reputations for quality. What sets them apart from others is the breadth of their product offerings, ensuring that you can find a suitable solution tailored to your specific needs.
Is Goodman as good as Trane?
When it comes to selecting a heating and cooling system, homeowners often find themselves pondering the age-old question: what’s the difference between Goodman and Trane? While there may not be a straightforward answer, understanding the characteristics of each brand is crucial in making an informed decision for your home. Notably, Trane is generally regarded as a premium option compared to Goodman, with both brands offering diverse product ranges.
However, this doesn’t necessarily mean that Goodman systems are subpar – they can indeed be a fantastic choice for many homeowners.
Is Amana and Goodman the same company?
While Goodman and Amana share a common parentage under the Goodman umbrella, the two brands cater to different segments of the market. Amana’s product portfolio is characterized by higher-end offerings that often come with a premium price tag. For customers seeking more budget-friendly options, Goodman’s lineup may be a more viable choice, offering a balance between quality and affordability.
Who is the largest heat pump manufacturer?
When it comes to heat pumps, Carrier takes the top spot as the world’s largest manufacturer. Trane and Goodman follow closely behind, with Rheem completing the top four. If you’re searching for a reliable brand that offers a range of products to suit your specific needs, these industry giants are definitely worth considering.
Are Kerr heat pumps any good?
While not as well-known as other brands, Kerr heat pumps are certainly not inferior. Their products are often viewed as a cost-effective option without sacrificing quality. If you’re searching for a mid-range solution that won’t put a dent in your wallet, Kerr is definitely worth considering. It’s worth noting that the brand also offers reliable alternatives for other appliances, such as refrigerators, washing machines, and dishwashers.
Conclusion
When selecting a heat pump brand for your home, it’s crucial to prioritize efficiency, reliability, durability, and comfort. This significant investment will have a lasting impact on your daily life, making it essential to choose a top-of-the-line model that meets your needs. While budget is certainly a consideration, it’s equally important to weigh performance, reliability, and the overall value proposition offered by each brand.
Related Posts
In today’s market, finding the right dehumidifier for your basement can be a daunting task. With so many options available, it’s essential to consider factors such as humidity levels, noise levels, and energy efficiency. That’s why we’ve compiled a list of the top 16 dehumidifiers for basements in 2024, taking into account key features and customer reviews.
Whether you’re dealing with dampness or moisture issues, this comprehensive guide will help you make an informed decision when purchasing your ideal dehumidifier. Additionally, we’ll be covering tips on how to troubleshoot common HVAC issues, including furnace malfunctions and central air conditioning system problems. By staying up-to-date on the latest solutions and maintenance best practices, homeowners can enjoy a comfortable living space all year round.
