5 Worst Carpet Brands To Avoid And 6 Most Reliable Brands

When selecting a carpet for your home, it’s not just about finding the right color or pattern. Carpets also serve practical purposes like making a space child-friendly, controlling traffic flow, and providing comfort underfoot. However, not all carpets are created equal. It’s crucial to be aware of the brands that may not meet your expectations. In this guide, we’ll objectively evaluate some top carpet brands and identify those you should avoid.

This information is essential before making a purchase, so take the time to read on before buying.

Carpet buying guide

Carpet buying guide

To steer clear of subpar carpet brands, it’s crucial to comprehend the key indicators that set apart high-quality from low-quality products. By recognizing these red flags, you’ll be better equipped to identify potential lemon brands and make informed decisions when selecting a new carpet. Here’s a comprehensive list of essential factors to consider in your search for the perfect carpet:

Weight and density

When it comes to measuring the quality of a carpet, weight and density are crucial factors. Specifically, good carpets typically weigh in at 25-50 ounces. What’s more, the heavier and denser the carpet is, the greater its visual impact, cushioning, and overall lifespan will be.

Carpet material

When it comes to carpets, the choice of fabric is crucial. While various options have their unique strengths and weaknesses, a select few stand out for their exceptional versatility. Top contenders include nylon, olefin, polyester, cotton, wool, and sisal – each bringing its own distinct qualities to the table.

Carpet style

When it comes to selecting the perfect carpet for your space, understanding the different styles is crucial. The three main categories of carpet styles are cut pile, loop pile, and cut and loop pile. Each style has its unique characteristics, making some more suitable for specific environments than others. Cut piles are generally ideal for residential settings, offering a soft and luxurious feel.

On the other hand, loop piles are better suited for high-traffic areas or commercial spaces, as they can withstand heavier use. The cut and loop pile style offers a versatile option that can seamlessly blend into both residential and commercial settings.

Resistance and maintenance

To evaluate a carpet’s performance, it’s essential to gather information from multiple sources. Start by researching online reviews and gathering feedback from friends who have had firsthand experience with a particular brand’s carpets. When assessing a carpet’s quality, consider its ability to resist stains, fading, and twisting/looping. Moreover, a good carpet should be low-maintenance, featuring easy cleaning and the option for bleaching if needed.

By considering these factors, you’ll be well-equipped to make an informed decision when selecting a new carpet.


When evaluating carpet brands, regardless of price point, it’s crucial to consider the manufacturer’s commitment to backing its products with a comprehensive warranty and exceptional customer service. A reputable brand will have a clear warranty policy in place, ensuring customers receive support for any issues that may arise. Furthermore, prompt and helpful responses from the company’s customer service team are essential indicators of a good carpet brand.

5 Worst Carpet Brands To Avoid

When it comes to choosing the right carpet for your home or commercial space, it’s essential to know which brands to avoid and why. To help you make an informed decision, we’ve compiled a list of some of the worst carpet brands based on real-life experiences from homeowners, designers, and contractors, as well as general star ratings from major online retailers.

Capel Rugs

Capel Rugs

Capel Rugs, a well-established name in the American household for all things rugs and carpets, has faced a decline in recent years. The company’s star rating and customer satisfaction have taken a hit due to issues with their carpet quality. Over the past five years, several problems have emerged, including fibers sprouting after just five to seven washes, the rug rippling under high humidity conditions, and losing thickness, becoming matted and crushed in areas with heavy foot traffic.

Additionally, the carpets tend to trap dusts in the loops, are not stain-resistant, and come with a relatively short warranty period.

StainMaster Carpet

StainMaster Carpet

This brand stands out for its consistent style, colors, and patterns, which appeals to customers seeking variety at an affordable price point. While their products initially impress, several concerns have emerged through customer reviews and testimonials.

Specifically, users have reported issues with: The color fading after repeated washing, loops that readily attract dirt, a short lifespan due to matting and crushing, difficulty in removing stains, and doubts surrounding the warranty’s legitimacy. These criticisms have led many homeowners to question the brand’s quality and value.

Mohawk Carpets

Mohawk Carpets

Mohawk Carpets, a 200-year-old reputable brand, has faced subtle criticisms over the years. However, with the rise of online reviews and ratings, these concerns have gained momentum. While they’re known for their modern, vibrant, and unconventional designs, several drawbacks have emerged from carpet reviews and market ratings. Specifically, some users have reported that stains are notoriously difficult to remove, resulting in a worn-out appearance reminiscent of buying a new carpet altogether.

Additionally, the carpets tend to lose weight, density, and pile fiber easily, compromising their overall performance. Furthermore, quality ratings for Mohawk Carpets are often categorized as below average to average, indicating a need for improvement. Moreover, some critics argue that their designs have become stale and less competitive compared to newer trends.

Shaw Carpet

Shaw Carpet

Shaw Carpet, once a stalwart in the industry, has unfortunately found itself on this list due to the proliferation of unauthorized reselling stores peddling subpar products. As one of the largest and most established carpet mills in the US, Shaw Carpet is synonymous with affordable prices and forward-thinking designs. However, this reputation has been tarnished by the emergence of these fly-by-night sellers, which have led to a host of quality control issues.

Specifically, their products are prone to absorbing dirt and stains, patterns and textures can fade significantly within just 12 months, and there may be problems with carpet pigmentation. Moreover, the main company appears reluctant to honor warranty claims even from authorized distributors, further eroding consumer trust.

Karastan Carpet

Karastan Carpet

While it may come as a surprise, this company is another notable entry for its use of an exclusive, patented strand in manufacturing carpets. With over 130 styles to choose from across various fabric types and materials, the brand offers a wide range of options. However, it’s essential to note that the quality of their products has left many customers underwhelmed, particularly those who purchased items online.

Several issues have been reported, including: The need for professional cleaning to effectively remove simple dirt and mud. Regular vacuuming can cause frills and damage to the carpet’s edges. Concerns about easy splitting and tearing. Problems with matting and crushing. Furthermore, some customers have expressed dissatisfaction with the brand’s warranty enforcement.

6 Most Reliable Carpet Brands

While it’s true that not all carpet brands have impressed, there are certainly many reputable ones that have consistently delivered high-quality products. As we delve into the world of carpets, let’s take a closer look at some of the most dependable and reliable brands that have earned their stripes over the years.



This renowned luxury flooring brand boasts an extensive collection of thousands of premium carpets that exude durability and longevity. The brand’s products have earned the admiration of both customers and home contractors alike, thanks to their impressive attributes, including exceptional strength, density, and vibrant, eclectic patterns. Additionally, they offer stain-resistant and non-fade properties that ensure their carpets remain looking fresh for years to come.

Some notable selling points include a specialization in nylon and wool carpets, compliance with the rigorous Green Label Plus certification, hypoallergenic designs, and the ability to withstand moisture and high humidity environments without emitting unpleasant odors.



This renowned brand boasts an impressive track record, consistently ranking high in online ratings with a staggering 4.5 out of 5-star average customer review score over the past seven years. What sets them apart is their focus on delivering hard-wearing, innovative designs that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. With a vast array of colors, thicknesses, textures, and carpet grades to choose from, customers are spoiled for choice.

What’s more, this brand excels in several key areas, including:
• A comprehensive selection of pet-friendly carpets tailored to meet the needs of furry friends and their owners.
• An astonishing 10,000+ styles, patterns, colors, and shades to choose from, ensuring that there’s something for everyone.
• Customizable color palettes that allow customers to put their personal stamp on their chosen carpet.

• Impressive color-retaining capabilities and stain-resistance features that guarantee durability and low maintenance.

Anderson Tuftex

Anderson Tuftex

This renowned brand has consistently pushed the boundaries of innovative carpet design, showcasing exceptional mastery over twisted and tight constructions, vibrant color palettes, modern lines, and intricate patterned weaves. Their collection also boasts an impressive array of natural tones, further solidifying their expertise in natural fiber carpet manufacturing.

What sets this highly-regarded brand apart is its commitment to delivering high-quality products that meet the demands of upscale, formal spaces and commercial environments. Key selling points include: a reputation for durability, boasting exceptional resistance to stains, crushing, and matting; a lifespan of up to 15 years; and a strong focus on providing excellent customer service and comprehensive warranty coverage.


Standing out from its peers in terms of both quality and sustainability, Dupont’s carpet takes the top spot in 2020 and first half of 2021 carpet review rankings. As a science-backed brand, it proudly touts its eco-friendly approach to carpet production as its primary selling point. In addition to this key feature, consumers can also look forward to the following benefits: Durable enough for high-traffic areas, it’s hypoallergenic and well-suited for homes with pets or children.

The carpet is also remarkably easy to clean and resistant to stains, smudges, and dirt, ensuring its texture, thickness, and shape remain intact for years to come.

Engineered Flooring LLC

Engineered Flooring LLC
Engineered Flooring LLC

This brand’s acquisition of Beaulieu America, once the third largest carpet manufacturing company globally, has yielded a lasting legacy in the form of the iconic Bliss Carpet. To this day, they continue to produce this renowned product, boasting an extensive range of thousands of carpet selections. This includes carpet tile and wall-to-wall options featuring a diverse palette of nylon, polyester, olefin, and fabric combinations.

According to customer feedback, the selling points that have made Bliss so well-loved include:

81 distinctive designs,
10 vibrant colors,
and hundreds of patterns, textures, and carpet grading options available.

nThe brand’s innovative features also set it apart, including Magic Fresh odor treatment and Silver Release antimicrobial treatment.

Additionally, Bliss offers room-specific carpet catalogues, ensuring that customers can find the perfect solution for their unique space.

And with affordable selections to suit various budgets, it’s no wonder this brand remains a favorite among consumers.

Atlas Carpet Mills

Atlas Carpet Mills

Atlas, a renowned high-end carpet brand, is the go-to choice for luxury home projects. Their impressive range of patterns and colors sets them apart from the rest. Not only do they offer a wide array of options, but also provide customizable carpets that cater to both residential and commercial settings. Consistently receiving rave reviews, Atlas boasts an impressive 5-star rating across their four flagship carpet collections: Bellissimo, Metafora, Metropolitan, Momentum, and Ville Des Lumieres.

Each collection offers its unique charm, making them a favorite among design enthusiasts and professionals alike.

Mistakes to avoid when buying a carpet

As we’ve already explored the top-performing and underwhelming carpet manufacturers, along with a comprehensive buyer’s guide to help you make an informed decision, it’s essential to be aware of common pitfalls to sidestep when selecting the perfect carpet for your home. In this section, we’ll shine a light on some key mistakes to avoid during the buying process.

Move on from carpet weight

While it’s true that quantifying face weight can provide a general guideline, it doesn’t necessarily mean that heavier carpets are always better than lighter ones. A thicker or heavier carpet may not automatically trump one that is thinner and lighter in density and face weight. In fact, the proven density range of 25-50 oz only tells part of the story. When selecting a carpet, it’s also important to consider the impact of loops and twists on overall weight and performance.

Never skip the padding

When it comes to installing carpets, making a costly error can have long-term consequences. One such mistake is neglecting the padding or underlayment, which provides multiple benefits. Not only does it offer comfortable cushioning for your feet, but also acts as an insulating layer protecting the floor and enhancing the overall stability and durability of your carpet.

Furthermore, a well-executed underlayment can give your carpet a more luxurious appearance, making it a worthwhile investment in the long run.

No, carpets are not the same

It’s a common misconception to assume that all carpets are created equal, simply because they share a similar appearance and functionality. However, what many people fail to consider is that each carpet has its own unique characteristics, making it more suitable for specific rooms or environments. For instance, certain carpet fibers are designed specifically for low-traffic areas, while others can withstand the wear and tear of high-traffic spaces.

Ultimately, it’s the subtle differences that set one carpet apart from another, requiring a closer examination of the details to determine which is best suited for your needs.

Incorrect square footage calculation

When it comes to buying carpets, measuring your floor area is a crucial step that can save you from surprises later on. Calculating the total cost of carpeting becomes much easier with an accurate estimate of your floor’s square footage. But here’s the thing: the square footage alone isn’t enough to give you a precise idea of what you’ll need. Leave it to the salesperson or a professional to determine the correct carpet measurement for your space.

Promotions are just promotions sometimes

Some companies may appear to offer affordable options, but upon closer inspection, hidden charges can significantly inflate the total cost. For instance, low-rated carpet providers might initially quote a lower price for their products, only to reveal additional fees during the installation process. These surprise expenses can add up quickly and leave customers feeling taken advantage of. It’s essential to exercise caution and thoroughly research any company before making a purchase.

Professional installation

While it may be tempting to take on a DIY carpet installation project or ask a friend to do it for you, it’s essential to carefully consider the pros and cons before making a decision. One of the primary concerns with DIY carpet installation is the risk of rippling and buckling, which can occur when there is a lack of understanding about the existing flooring conditions and humidity levels in the room.

In reality, carpet installation involves more than just gluing or stretching the carpet onto the floor. It requires a comprehensive approach that takes into account various factors, including the subfloor’s condition, moisture levels, and the type of carpet being used.

The wrong carpet for your lifestyle

When selecting a carpet for your home, it’s essential to consider both its functional suitability and aesthetic appeal in relation to your lifestyle and the room’s layout. Avoid choosing plush pile carpets for areas prone to heavy foot traffic or muddy messes, as they may prove impractical and require excessive maintenance.

Similarly, opt for durable, low-maintenance materials like synthetic fibers over luxurious options like wool if you’re short on time or not willing to commit to regular cleaning schedules. Ultimately, the carpet that best suits your needs is one that balances form with function.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the toughest carpet?

In terms of fabric composition, there are two standout options: nylon and its natural fiber counterparts like jute and sisal. Nylon is particularly notable for its versatility, boasting a range of benefits that make it well-suited for high-traffic areas. Its natural fibers allow it to effortlessly hide dirt and stains, while its ease of cleaning makes maintenance a breeze. On the other hand, when it comes to stain-resistance and durability, loop pile carpets are the clear winner.

Characterized by symmetrical strands, these carpets offer the softness and texture of plush, coupled with a density and thickness that contribute to their remarkable longevity.

What is the best grade of carpet?

High-end carpets, often considered the crème de la crème of carpet grades, boast impressive face weights and densities that fall within the 40-80 ounce range. With an estimated lifespan of 15-25 years, these premium options are designed to withstand the test of time. It’s essential to note that the term ‘high-end’ is not always synonymous with luxury; in fact, these carpets typically come with a price tag ranging from $35 to $80 and up.

What is the cheapest brand of carpet?

When it comes to affordable carpet options, four brands stand out as particularly budget-friendly – Shaw Floors, Stain Master, Mohawk, and Anderson Tuftex. Interestingly, Shaw Floors takes the crown as the cheapest of the group, with prices ranging from $0.80 to $3 per square foot. The other three brands offer slightly pricier options, with Stain Master falling in the $1.85-$3 range, Mohawk coming in at $2.45-$5, and Anderson Tuftex topping out at $5.50-$8.

What is the best luxury carpet brand?

When it comes to luxury carpets, there’s a distinct echelon that sets itself apart from the rest. Among these crème de la crème brands are four notable names that every discerning homeowner should have on their radar: Fabrica, Karastan, Masland Carpets, and Anderson Tuftex. Each of these esteemed manufacturers has earned its reputation for producing exceptional quality, stunning designs, and unparalleled performance.

What is the best brand of carpet in the UK?

As we’ve explored the world of high-quality brands with global reach, it’s time to dive into the best carpet brands in the UK for 2023-2024. Let’s take a closer look at some of the most renowned names in the industry.

From Adam Carpets to Westex Carpets, we’ll be highlighting top brands like Alternative Flooring, Axminster Carpets, Brintons, Bristol Carpets, Cormar Carpets, Cavalier Carpets, Danfloor, Fibre Flooring, Hugh McKay Carpets, Newhey, Penthouse Carpets, Tapi Carpets, and Thomas Witter Carpets.

Get ready to discover the crème de la crème of carpet brands in the UK!

Are there eco-friendly carpet brands?

Several notable carpet brands have made it a priority to integrate environmentally sustainable practices into both their manufacturing processes and product lines. FLOR and Interface, for instance, offer eco-friendly carpet tile options crafted from recycled and sustainably sourced materials. These companies are dedicated to minimizing their ecological footprint while providing customers with a range of green choices that align with their own values.

What should I know about carpet warranties?

When considering a new carpet purchase, it’s essential to factor in the warranty that comes with it. Unbeknownst to many, warranties can differ greatly between brands and even within a brand’s product line offerings. These guarantees typically cover issues such as wear and tear, stains, and manufacturing defects. To make an informed decision and alleviate any concerns, it’s crucial to thoroughly read and comprehend the warranty details before making a purchase.

How important is carpet maintenance, and can it affect my choice of brand?

Extending the lifespan of your carpet relies heavily on regular maintenance. While different manufacturers may have unique care guidelines based on the carpet’s material composition, there are some fundamental principles to adhere to. A consistent routine of thorough vacuuming and swift stain removal is essential for preserving the carpet’s appearance and longevity. However, when it comes to deeper cleaning, seeking the expertise of a professional rug cleaning service can be a wise investment.

By entrusting your carpet to the hands of an experienced technician, you can ensure that it continues to look its absolute best and retains its value as long as possible – especially for premium brands that demand the highest level of care.

Can I install carpets from these brands myself, or do I need a professional?

While it’s possible to opt for DIY installation with certain carpet brands, many types of carpet benefit from professional expertise. When you hire a pro, you can rest assured that your new carpet will be fitted perfectly, finished beautifully, and perform optimally. Moreover, professional installers are equipped to identify and address any subfloor issues that might affect the overall quality of the installation.

Furthermore, they can ensure that the carpet is installed according to the manufacturer’s specifications – a crucial step in maintaining the warranty.

How do I get the best deal on carpets from these top brands?

To maximize your savings, it’s essential to shop around and compare prices across various retailers. Additionally, keep an eye out for ongoing sales or promotions that can help you snag the best deal. Some merchants may even offer attractive discounts on installation costs or provide special financing options when you purchase from them directly.

Moreover, subscribing to newsletters from brands and retailers can keep you informed about upcoming deals and exclusive offers, giving you a head start in making an informed purchasing decision.

Are there any recent trends in carpeting from these brands?

As the world continues to evolve towards a more environmentally conscious future, the flooring industry is embracing this shift by incorporating sustainable and eco-friendly materials into its designs. This movement has also led to the integration of cutting-edge technology aimed at enhancing stain resistance and durability.

Furthermore, textured and patterned carpets have gained immense popularity for their remarkable ability to conceal dirt and wear, making them an ideal choice for busy households. On the other hand, soft and plush carpets continue to remain a top pick for bedrooms and living areas, offering a luxurious feel that invites relaxation and comfort.


When selecting a carpet for your home, it’s essential to consider the brand behind the product rather than just its visual appeal or features. Not all carpet manufacturers deliver equally well on durability, making it crucial to research popular brands before making a final decision.

Rather than focusing solely on aesthetics and personal preference, prioritize quality in your carpet choice. This approach will ensure you’re investing in a product that can withstand the test of time.

By considering reputable brands and their offerings, you’ll be well-equipped to make an informed selection. With our previous insights serving as a guide, you now have a solid foundation for evaluating carpet options.

Similar Posts